Memories: Winston Churchill
Winston Churchill, who is best known
as Britain’s Prime Minister during the second world war wrote about his
unpleasant experiences as a very young schoolboy in the 1880s. His experience
was also featured in the film Young Winston and there is a clip of it here.
The Form Master’s observations about
punishment were by no means without their warrant at St George’s School.
Flogging with the birch in accordance with the Eton fashion was a great feature
in its curriculum. But I am sure no Eton boy, and certainly no Harrow boy of my
day, ever received such a cruel flogging as this Headmaster was accustomed to
inflict upon the little boys who were in his care and power. They exceeded in
severity anything that would be tolerated in any of the Reformatories under the
Home Office.
My reading in later life has supplied me
with some possible explanations of his temperament. Two or three times a month
the whole school was marshalled to the Library, and one or more delinquents
were hauled off to an adjoining apartment by the two head boys, and there
flogged until they bled freely, while the rest sat quaking, listening to their
screams. This form of correction was strongly reinforced by frequent religious
services of a somewhat High Church character in the chapel.
Extracted from: Winston Churchill,
My Early Life, (Thornton
Butterworth Limited: 1930).
Picture credits: Unknown.
For more True Memories,
click here
Traditional School Discipline
Traditionalschooldiscipline@gmail.com







Does Churchill's description mean that the floggings at St George's School were also with the birch? And if so then the 1972 movie is incorrect to show it as being with the cane? Deliberately incorrect? And if so why would they choose to change it like that? Maybe they just thought that the movie audience in 1972 would relate to the cane better? But that seems unnecessary if they intended to show it as excessive anyway.
ReplyDeleteIt's a very scary movie clip. Some of the rest of the movie is interesting too actually. But I think that's the only spanking in it.